Best Italian Restaurants in Reykjavik

The Best Italian Restaurants in Reykjavik

Whether you're looking for traditional dishes found in most Italian restaurants or inventive takes on the cuisine, here are the best places for Italian food in Reykjavik.

6. Duck and Rose

Photo from Duck and Rose

Duck and Rose is a popular Italian-inspired restaurant located in the heart of Reykjavik. With a cozy and welcoming atmosphere in a stylish environment, it's the perfect place for a casual meal with friends or a fun dinner date.

They offer great pizzas and pasta dishes, with the lemon tagliatelle being especially good! As the name of the restaurant implies, you can find some tasty duck dishes as well, like the duck confit and duck salad. If you're up for a sweet treat afterward, the meringue and white chocolate dessert is amazing.

For those stopping by for the brunch offer, don't miss out on the confit duck and waffle, or treat yourself to the two-hour luxury brunch, which includes bottomless drinks! They also have an affordable lunch offer on weekdays for the fish of the day, perfect when exploring Reykjavik.

Photo from Duck and Rose

If you happen to be in Reykjavik on those rare sunny summer days, you can enjoy sitting outside on the restaurant patio. It's just by Austurvollur square with views of the Althingi parliament building, and it's a popular place to relax with a beer or glass of wine while basking in the elusive sunshine.

If you're planning a night out to experience the famous Reykjavik nightlife, a dinner at Duck and Rose is a great way to start your evening of fun. It's very close to many popular clubs and bars!

Reserve your table at Duck and Rose restaurant

• Learn more: Reykjavik Nightlife Guide: The Best Bars and Clubs in Iceland
• See also: Iceland in Summer - The Ultimate Travel Guide

5. Ítalía

Photo from Veitingahúsið Ítalía

Sometimes, you're just craving a classic Italian meal as you would find it in Italy, with none of the frills of fusion restaurants or inventive new ingredients. So, where do you go to scratch that specific craving for a delicious lasagna or carbonara? Well, Ítalía, of course!

Ítalía is not only the Icelandic name for the country of Italy, but it also happens to be a fantastic Italian restaurant in central Reykjavik. It's been the go-to place among locals for classic Italian dishes since it opened in 1991, and it's become a bit of a landmark on the Laugavegur shopping street with its traditional Italian window shutters making it instantly recognizable.

Photo from Veitingahúsið Ítalía

Its recently upgraded menu features staples like tagliatelle alla bolognese, spaghetti carbonara, and our favorite, the lasagna. Also, save some space for the panna cotta dessert!

Of course, it's hard to call yourself a classic Italian restaurant without pizza, and Ítalía has plenty of great options to choose from. Paired with the nice wine list, friendly service, and relaxed atmosphere, you're in for a cozy night!

Book a table at Ítalía restaurant

• See more: The Ultimate Guide to Downtown Reykjavik

4. Caruso

Photo from Caruso Ísland

As you explore the downtown area of Reykjavik, you'll come across Austurstraeti 22, one of the oldest buildings in the city. It was built in 1801 and served as the Governor's House and the home of some significant figures in Iceland's history, like Jörgen Jörgensen, the Dog-Days King! Today, it's the home of Caruso, a classic Italian restaurant that's a favorite among locals and travelers alike.

Caruso is perfect for a relaxed lunch break or cozy dinner when sightseeing in Iceland's capital. The lunch menu is relatively affordable, as Reykjavik restaurants go, with plenty of classic pasta options, salads, meat, fish, and pizzas! The dinner menu offers the same range, with many more refined options to choose from. Try the risotto and any of their seafood dishes, and don't skip the garlic bread, as it's delicious!

Photo from Caruso Ísland

If you're hungry, we recommend taking their dinner offer, which includes a starter, main, and dessert. You'll be able to enjoy the range of Caruso's menu while relaxing in their comfortable setting.

Whether you're traveling with a partner, friends, or family, Caruso is a great option for a tasty Italian meal in Reykjavik. With friendly service, charming interior, and tasty food, make sure to add a visit to Caruso to your itinerary!

Reserve a table at Caruso restaurant now

• For more, check out the Most Infamous Icelanders of History
• See also: the History of Reykjavik and the Complete History of Iceland

3. Ráðagerði Restaurant

Photo from Ráðagerði Veitingahús

Hidden away near the edge of Seltjarnarnes is a historic building with an amazing view of the surrounding ocean and the Grotta nature reserve. Originally built between 1880 and 1885, this traditional Icelandic house is now home to the charming Ráðagerði restaurant!

It's only a 6-minute drive from central Reykjavik, and it's best to visit with a small rental car or city bus. It's the perfect place for brunch, romantic dinner, or a cozy night out with family or friends. You can try classic pasta dishes, delicious focaccias, lasagna, meatballs, and much more! The great pizza selection also deserves a special highlight, with plenty of classic and original options that are loved by locals.

Photo from Ráðagerði

This hidden gem is a must-visit if you're planning to explore the Grotta nature reserve. Make sure to plan your visit strategically!

Grotta is one of the most beautiful places to see the sunset in Reykjavik, and in winter, it is extremely popular for northern lights hunting within city limits. If these activities are on your Iceland itinerary, plan a dinner visit to Ráðagerði restaurant and enjoy a stroll along the coastline! If you're planning an active day exploring the nature and thriving birdlife of Grotta, you may prefer a brunch stop to spend the afternoon among nature. Either way, don't miss out on a visit to this special place for a true Italian treat in Reykjavik.

Reserve a table at Ráðagerði restaurant now!

• Learn more about the Best Places to See the Northern Lights in Reykjavik
• See also: Top 21 Parks in Reykjavik

2. La Primavera Ristorante

Photo from La Primavera in Harpan

If you're planning a special night out while in Reykjavik or simply want to treat yourself to a fine dining experience, then La Primavera is worth a visit. You'll find this North Italian restaurant in the Harpa concert hall in the city center and in the historic Marshall House in the Grandi area so you can choose which location best fits your itinerary.

La Primavera Ristorante originally opened in 1993 and specialises in bringing authentic Italian flavors to Iceland. The menu changes regularly, with a curated selection of three starters, three mains, and a dessert that highlights seasonal ingredients.

While the menu is different every visit, you can generally expect an interesting pasta option, with freshly-made pasta, a fresh seafood dish, and a delicious meat option. The wine list is also extensive, and the knowledgeable staff can help you find the perfect pairing for your meal.

Photo from La Primavera, in the Marshall House

La Primavera in Harpan sometimes offers special openings and events in connection to concerts, plays, and other performances going on in the concert house. If you'll be attending an event at Harpan, keep an eye out!

The location in the Marshall House is perfect for those seeking other cultural experiences in Reykjavik. The restaurant shares a space with the Living Art Museum, where you can find innovative contemporary art! As it's located in the Grandi area, you'll also be within walking distance of locations like the Reykjavik Maritime Museum, Flyover Iceland, the Whales of Iceland exhibition, and much more.

Whichever location you choose, you're in for a culinary delight that pairs nicely with any Reykjavik itinerary.

Book your table at La Primavera in Harpan or in the Marshall House!

• See also: The Best Live Music Venues in Iceland

1. Grazie Trattoria

The recently opened Grazie Trattoria is quickly gaining traction as the best Italian restaurant in Iceland, making it the place to go for those craving genuine Italian flavors while in Reykjavik.

This cozy restaurant is located on Hverfisgata street and has made a name for itself with traditional Italian recipes using fresh, quality ingredients. The menu features pasta, meat, and fish, and we especially recommend the delicious tagliatelle al ragu, the lasagna al forno, and polette Italiane for a fantastic dinner!

Grazie Trattoria also has some great pizzas, which are expertly prepared and baked in a wood-fired oven. The atmosphere is also warm, friendly, and welcoming, making it a great place for a relaxed meal or a more special occasion.

For wine lovers, Grazie Trattoria doesn’t disappoint, as they have a thoughtfully selected range of wines to match their dishes. If you can, try to save a bit of space for dessert, especially the crostata di mele! It's the perfect end to your Italian meal.

Grazie Trattoria is definitely a must-visit for anyone in Reykjavik looking for a slice of Italy. Make sure to include a visit on your Reykjavik itinerary, as it's sure to be one of the highlights of your trip!

Reserve a table at Grazie Trattoria now!

Honorable mention: OTO

Photo from OTO Restaurant

This restaurant is a bit of a wildcard on this list since it doesn't quite fit the typical Italian restaurant ideal. That's why it's included as an honorable mention – it's just too good to leave out!

If you're interested in tasting innovative and interesting interpretations of Italian dishes, OTO is a must-try, as it offers a fusion of Italian and Japanese cuisine. The menu features some familiar dishes, like an absolutely delicious pumpkin ravioli or a burrata with figs and hazelnuts, which we can't stop thinking about.

You'll also see interesting combinations like the tagliatelle with salsiccia and taberu rayu and the artichoke with pine nuts and bagnet verd sauce. Don't miss out on some of the best tiramisu in Reykjavik, either! We recommend trying their tasting menu for a true culinary adventure, as you'll get to taste the whole range of flavors on offer.

OTO is perfect for a unique fine dining experience in Reykjavik, so include a visit on your itinerary!

Reserve your table at OTO restaurant now!

Best Italian Pizzerias in Reykjavik

While most of the restaurants mentioned here serve great pizzas, these establishments are entirely dedicated to the heavenly treat that everyone loves. These are the best Italian pizzerias in Reykjavik!

3. Olifa - La Madre Pizza

Photo from OLIFA - La Madre Pizza

The recently opened Olifa - La Madre Pizza offers a very different take on pizza. They serve pizza alla pala, or "paddle pizza," which is known for its airy and slightly crispy crust, baked in large rectangular trays.

Olifa - La Madre Pizza uses quality Italian ingredients, many of which are directly imported by the Olifa brand itself! In fact, you can find a range of Olifa's quality Italian products in Icelandic grocery stores, underscoring their commitment to bringing authentic Italian flavors to Iceland.

Photo from OLIFA - La Madre Pizza

Olifa - La Madre Pizza is especially great if you're visiting with family or a group, as you can order a few options of pala pizza and share. Your pizza is served on a large wooden tray, making it easy to mix and match slices. The pancetta and speck pizzas are especially delicious, and try the garlic bread! The tartufo is also very good if you want to treat yourself to something special.

This pizza place is located on Sudulandsbraut 12, a 25-minute walk from the Hlemmur area, so it's a bit outside the city center. However, it's worth the detour if you want to try a different kind of pizza or if you are staying in any of the many Reykjavik hotels in the vicinity.

Book a table at Olifa - La Madre Pizza in Reykjavik

2. Flatey Pizza

Photo from Flatey

Flatey is likely the most popular place for a casual traditional Italian pizza in Iceland, with a delicious selection of Neapolitan-style options. Their original location is in the Grandi area, but you'll find this pizzeria in many of the food halls in the Capital Region. In the Hafnartorg food hall, you'll also find their sister restaurant, Neo Pizza, which serves New York-style pizza.

Flatey pizza is known for its lightly charred sourdough crust with quality toppings. We highly recommend the Umberto pizza, which has lightly crispy pepperoni, dates, and mascarpone. It's one of the most popular options on the menu for a reason, and it goes perfectly with a cold beer or glass of white wine! You can get it as part of the weekday lunch offer, which includes more of their most popular pizza options.

Photo from Flatey

This is a great, family-friendly location for a tasty pizza when exploring Reykjavik. It's just across the street from the Saga Museum, Aurora Reykjavik, and the Reykjavik Maritime Museum, so it's easy to plan a visit while in the area!

Throughout most of the day, you can simply walk into their location in Grandi, but if you want to visit for lunch or dinner, it's much better to book a table ahead of time as it can get crowded. If the weather is nice, you can also get takeaway and enjoy your pizza while admiring the view from the nearby Reykjavik harbor!

Book your table at Flatey now

• Learn more about food in Iceland with the Ultimate Guide to Iceland Food Culture

1. BakaBaka

If you've done any research into the food scene in Reykjavik, you've likely come across the BakaBaka bakery. It was opened by the same people as the famous Brauð & Co, and both of these regularly compete for the title of the best bakery in Reykjavik. What makes BakaBaka deserve a place on this list, however, it's that it transforms into a fantastic pizzeria once the sun goes down!

BakaBaka used to offer a variety of Italian dishes, but the pizzas were simply the favorites on the menu, so they've decided to dedicate their evening menu to its biggest stars! It's where you'll find some of the best pizzas in Reykjavik, with excellent classic and original options to choose from.

Some of the special highlights on the menu are the Parma ham pizza, with mozzarella, rucola, and parmesan, or the tasty mortadella, with stracciatella lemon oil and pistachio! To accompany your delicious meal, make sure to check out the curated wine list.

Photo from Baka Baka

You'll find BakaBaka in an iconic house in downtown Reykjavik, Bankastraeti 2. It was originally built in 1834 for the first bakery in Iceland, and the restaurant has beautifully preserved the traditional charm of the building. The interior features exposed wood beams, rustic wooden stairs, and a slanted ceiling. All of this adds to the cozy and charming atmosphere, making it the perfect place for a casual romantic dinner or a fun night out in Reykjavik.

Book a table at BakaBaka restaurant!

• Learn more about the Best Bakeries in Reykjavik

Summary of the Best Italian Restaurants in Reykjavik

Reykjavik's Italian restaurant scene offers an impressive array of choices, from traditional, cozy establishments to innovative fusion cuisine. Each place brings its own slice of Italy to Iceland, ensuring that lovers of Italian cuisine can find something to satisfy their cravings during a visit!

Whether it's a date night, a family dinner, or just craving some delicious pasta or pizza in Reykjavik, these fantastic Italian restaurants have you covered. So, next time you're in town, don't miss out on these gems – they're sure to add some extra flavor to your Icelandic adventure!

Will you try any of these Italian restaurants during your trip to Iceland? Have you visited any restaurants in Reykjavik before? Are there any Italian places we missed that deserve a highlight? Share your thoughts and experience in the comments below!