Renting a car and joining tours in Iceland offer entirely different experiences: one gives you more freedom, while the other lets you sit back and enjoy the ride as someone else takes the wheel.
Why You Can Trust Our Content
Guide to Iceland is the most trusted travel platform in Iceland, helping millions of visitors each year. All our content is written and reviewed by local experts who are deeply familiar with Iceland. You can count on us for accurate, up-to-date, and trustworthy travel advice.
Self-drive tours in Iceland can be an adventure on their own. Long open roads cut through lava fields, past glaciers, and along dramatic coastlines. But Iceland’s weather and road conditions can change fast, which is why many travelers prefer day tours in Iceland or guided multi-day trips for peace of mind.
In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know before you decide whether to join a tour or rent a car in Iceland. By the end, you’ll know exactly how to explore the country in a way that suits your preferences best.
Guided Tours vs Rental Cars in Iceland: At a Glance
-
Solo Travelers: Guided tours in Iceland are safer and stress-free for solo traveling, while rental cars work if you’re confident driving solo.
-
Groups & Families: Tours handle logistics and cost-sharing easily, while self-drive offers privacy and flexibility.
-
Summer Travel: Tours simplify planning, while rental cars and summer self-drive tours allow exploration of remote areas.
-
Winter Travel: Guided tours are safest, and driving in Iceland during the winter months is only for experienced drivers.
-
Flexibility: Rental cars give full control over itinerary and stops, but tours offer convenience and expert planning.
-
First-Time Visitors: Tours help you see the top places in Iceland efficiently with expert insights, while renting a car makes it simple to see all the top attractions by the Ring Road.
-
Budget: Guided tours can be cost-effective for groups, but rental cars and budget self-drive tours may save money for small parties or those who want a customizable trip.
-
Short Trips: Guided tours maximize sightseeing without stressing over planning.
-
Longer Trips: Rental cars give freedom to explore at your own pace and visit Iceland’s hidden and less-visited spots.
When To Choose Guided Tours in Iceland
If you prefer to skip the stress of driving on the country’s unpredictable roads, joining a guided tour might be a better option. Tours in Iceland are perfect for travelers who want to see the highlights without worrying about road conditions, navigation, or car rental details.
Whether it’s quick day trips from Reykjavik or multi-day adventures around Iceland, tours let you relax and simply enjoy the scenery.
What To Expect on a Guided Tour in Iceland
Most guided tours in Iceland include transport, a local driver-guide, and a planned itinerary covering Iceland’s top attractions. You can visit famous sites like the Golden Circle, the Reykjanes Peninsula, and the Snaefellsnes Peninsula.
For a broader adventure, explore Iceland’s dramatic landscapes on nature tours. And if chasing stunning cascades is your goal, waterfall tours take you to the best waterfalls in Iceland, like those in the South Coast.
Pickup is usually from Reykjavik, though some tours can arrange pickup from other main towns. You’ll ride in a minibus or coach, and along the way, your guide will share stories, local tips, and Icelandic history. Guided tours are also a social experience, perfect for meeting other travelers or for anyone not comfortable driving in Iceland.
Pros and Cons of Joining Guided Tours in Iceland
Choosing a guided tour in Iceland comes with plenty of perks, especially if you prefer a stress-free, well-organized way to see the country’s highlights. But while convenient, they also come with a few trade-offs that might not suit every kind of traveler.
|
Pros of Guided Tours in Iceland |
Cons of Guided Tours in Iceland |
|
Zero driving stress: You won’t need to worry about winter storms, gravel roads, or parking at crowded sites. |
Less flexibility: Tours follow fixed routes and schedules, so there’s little room for spontaneous detours or longer photo stops. |
|
Expert local insight: Guides often share fascinating stories, Icelandic folklore, and practical tips that you wouldn’t get from a GPS. |
Group dynamics: Depending on the tour, you might be with a larger crowd or spend time waiting for others. |
|
Time-efficient: With itineraries already planned, tours make the most of limited days in Iceland. |
Limited access: Some tours skip remote or hidden gems that are easier to reach on a self-drive trip in Iceland. |
|
Safety and comfort: Perfect if you’re visiting Iceland in winter or are unfamiliar with driving. |
Cost per person: For groups, guided tours may cost more than renting a car and exploring on your own. |
|
Social experience: Great for solo travelers who want company along the way. |
When To Rent a Car in Iceland
If you love the idea of exploring Iceland on your own terms, renting a car gives you the freedom to see the sights at your own pace. It’s an excellent choice for travelers who want flexibility, control over their itinerary, and the chance to discover less-visited spots that most tours don’t reach.
What To Expect When Renting a Car in Iceland
Renting a budget car in Iceland gives you full control over your schedule. You can stop whenever a view catches your eye, explore remote regions like the Westfjords, and adjust plans based on the weather.
Most travelers pick up their car rental in Keflavik after landing and drive straight from the airport. Others may arrange a rental car in Reykjavik or Akureyri, depending on their itinerary.
The Ring Road connects most major attractions, and if you’re comfortable driving in varying conditions, such as gravel roads, wind, or snow, you’ll find it one of the most rewarding ways to explore.
Pros and Cons of Renting a Car in Iceland
Renting a car in Iceland comes with several key benefits, giving you control and flexibility that guided tours simply can’t match. However, it also comes with responsibilities and challenges that every traveler should consider.
|
Pros of Renting a Car in Iceland |
Cons of Renting a Car in Iceland |
|
Total freedom: You set your own pace and choose when and where to stop. |
Challenging driving conditions: Narrow roads, unpredictable weather, and limited visibility can be stressful, especially in winter. |
|
Access to hidden gems: Reach remote areas, small villages, and scenic viewpoints that guided tours may not include. |
Extra responsibilities: You’ll need to plan routes, book accommodations, and handle fuel stops yourself. |
|
Cost-effective for groups: Splitting rental, fuel, and accommodation costs often makes it cheaper than joining multiple tours. |
Higher upfront costs: Car insurance, fuel, and rental deposits can add up, especially for SUVs and 4x4 vehicles. |
|
Great for photographers: Ideal for following the best Iceland itineraries for photographers, letting you capture the sunrise or the northern lights without a schedule. |
Parking and navigation issues: Popular attractions can get crowded, and finding parking in Reykjavik can be tricky. |
|
Flexible itinerary: Change plans easily if the weather shifts or a local recommends a new spot. |
Tiring for long distances: Some drives, like across the South Coast or to the Eastfjords, can take several hours each way. |
8 Questions To Ask When Planning Your Iceland Trip
Choosing how to explore Iceland, whether on a self-drive trip or with guided tours, depends on several important factors, especially when planning first-time visits. Here’s what to consider before making your decision.
1. How long is my trip to Iceland?
The length of your trip can make a big difference in whether you should rent a car in Iceland or join guided tours. For short trips (2–4 days), especially first-time visits, day tours in Iceland are often the easiest way to see the highlights without worrying about planning or driving.
For longer trips (7+ days), self-drive tours in Iceland give you the freedom to explore at your own pace and visit remote regions that tours may skip. This flexibility makes it perfect for a 7-day or 10-day itinerary in Iceland to see its highlights and hidden gems.
2. What season will I be visiting Iceland?
The weather in Iceland changes quickly, which affects the choice between rental cars and guided tours in Iceland.
Winter in Iceland brings icy roads, snow, and strong winds, making driving more challenging and sometimes unsafe for inexperienced drivers. Many travelers prefer winter tours and packages to enjoy the sights safely without the stress of driving.
Meanwhile, summer in Iceland brings the midnight sun and long daylight hours, with more predictable road conditions. This makes it ideal for summer self-drive tours and exploring independently.
3. Am I comfortable with driving in Iceland?
Your driving experience and comfort with planning are also crucial. Driving in Iceland often involves gravel roads, one-lane bridges, and sudden weather changes.
Understanding car insurance, fuel stops, and routes is essential for a self-drive trip in Iceland. If you’re uncomfortable with these responsibilities, guided tours in Iceland remove the stress while still letting you see the major attractions.
4. What’s my budget, and how large is my group?
Solo travelers in Iceland often find tours more cost-effective since car rental, fuel, and insurance can be expensive. Groups can split the costs of renting a car in Iceland, making it cheaper and more flexible than joining multiple tours.
For groups looking to save even more or add an extra layer of adventure, motorhomes and campervans are great options. They combine transport and accommodation, giving you freedom while keeping costs down.
5. Do I want to explore Iceland at my own pace and schedule?
If you want to control your itineraries in Iceland, linger at scenic spots, or chase the northern lights, a self-drive trip in Iceland is ideal. Guided tours in Iceland follow set schedules, which is efficient but limits spontaneity. Renting a car allows you to adjust your route and stop for unexpected photo opportunities or local recommendations.
6. Do I want to access remote regions or the Icelandic Highlands?
Some of Iceland’s most spectacular sights, like the Highlands or Westfjords, are difficult to reach without a rental vehicle. For these areas, a self-drive trip in Iceland, usually with a 4x4 rental car, is essential.
If you’d rather go for a guided experience, there are still Icelandic Highlands tours and Westfjords adventures available. However, these are less frequent and often more specialized than the popular Golden Circle tours or South Coast trips.
7. Do I want control over where to stay and how to get around in Iceland?
With renting a car, you can choose where to stay in Iceland and adjust your route based on hotel availability or personal preference. Tours usually pre-book all accommodations, which is convenient but less flexible. If having control over lodging and travel timing is important, self-driving is the better option.
8. Do I want to handle the airport pickup and car rental process myself?
A self-drive trip in Iceland requires planning for car rental pick-up and drop-off, usually at Keflavik International Airport, as well as timing your itinerary and stops along the way.
Most guided tours in Iceland handle all transport logistics, letting you start sightseeing immediately without worrying about driving or planning routes. Alternatively, airport transfers can be arranged for a hassle-free start and end to your trip.
Self-Drive Tours vs Vacation Packages in Iceland
If you’re still weighing your options, another way to approach your Iceland trip is by comparing self-drive tours with vacation packages. Both let you explore the country, but one gives you full freedom behind the wheel while the other takes care of logistics and planning for you.
What Are Self-Drive Tours in Iceland?
Self-drive tours in Iceland let you rent a car and follow either a planned or flexible route as you explore the country on your own terms. You set the itinerary, choose your stops, and decide how long to spend at each location, whether you’re on a quick 3-day self-drive trip to the South Coast or a full 10-day northern lights Ring Road adventure.
There are summer self-drive tours with long daylight hours and easier road conditions, and winter self-drive tours designed for travelers comfortable with snow and icy roads who want to experience ice caves and northern lights.
You’ll also find luxury self-drive tours with premium hotels and vehicles, as well as budget self-drive tours that keep costs low while still covering Iceland’s major highlights.
Pros & Cons of Self-Drive Tours In Iceland
Taking a self-drive tour in Iceland comes with its own set of advantages and challenges. Here’s a quick look at the main pros and cons to help you decide if it’s the right choice for your trip.
|
Pros of Self-Drive Tours in Iceland |
Cons of Self-Drive Tours in Iceland |
|
Total flexibility: You can linger at scenic viewpoints, adjust your route, and decide how fast or slow you want each day to be. |
Challenging driving conditions: Winter weather, gravel roads, strong winds, and one-lane bridges require confidence and caution, especially for first-time visitors. |
|
Access to hidden gems: Remote areas, small villages, and lesser-known stops are easier to reach when you’re behind the wheel. |
Route responsibility: Even with an itinerary provided, you’re still the one navigating, watching road conditions, and checking weather alerts. |
|
Ideal for photographers and adventurers: You can time sunrise, sunset, and northern lights searching without worrying about a tour schedule. |
Higher upfront costs: Renting a car, especially a 4×4, plus fuel and optional insurance upgrades, can add up quickly. |
|
Accommodations included: Self-drive packages already come with pre-booked hotels or guesthouses, so you don’t need to secure rooms yourself. |
Driving fatigue: Long drives, constant focus, and changing road conditions can be tiring, especially on routes like the South Coast or across the Eastfjords. |
|
Customizable options: You can often upgrade vehicles, add 4×4, choose insurance levels, or tweak the itinerary to fit your comfort and travel style better. |
What Are Vacation Packages in Iceland?
Vacation packages in Iceland combine accommodations, transportation, and guided tours into a single itinerary. They’re perfect for travelers who want a stress-free experience with logistics handled.
You can choose from a variety of options to match your travel style, schedule, and season, ensuring there’s a vacation package in Iceland for every type of traveler.
Holiday packages are designed around Christmas and New Year, often including festive events, cozy accommodations, and seasonal activities like holiday markets or winter walks. Weekend breaks and short northern lights trips to Iceland focus on a few key highlights for travelers with limited time.
Winter vacation packages are tailored for ice caves, snowy landscapes, and northern lights chasing, while summer vacation packages take advantage of long daylight hours for scenic drives, adventure tours, and shore excursions.
Pros & Cons of Vacation Packages in Iceland
Vacation packages in Iceland are perfect for travelers who want a hassle-free experience, with guides, transport, and accommodations all arranged. Below, we break down the key benefits and drawbacks to help you see if this option fits your travel style.
|
Pros of Vacation Packages in Iceland |
Cons of Vacation Packages in Iceland |
|
Stress-free planning: Everything is organized, from transport to accommodations. |
Less flexibility: Tours follow set schedules, leaving little room for spontaneous detours. |
|
Safe and guided: Professional guides handle driving, navigation, and safety, especially in winter. |
Limited access to remote areas: Highlands, Westfjords, and hidden spots may be skipped. |
|
Ideal for solo travelers or short trips: No need to rent a car or manage logistics. |
Higher cost for groups: Small groups might pay more than if they self-drive. |
|
Customizable options: You can often upgrade accommodations, add extra guided tours, or include optional activities at an additional cost. |
Practical Tips for Your Iceland Trip
Exploring Iceland can be amazing, but a little planning goes a long way. Whether you choose a guided tour or a self-drive adventure, these tips will help you make the most of your trip, stay safe, and enjoy the country’s incredible landscapes.
Planning Your Trip with Guided Tours in Iceland
-
Book in advance: Popular tours in Iceland, like Golden Circle tours or South Coast trips, can fill up quickly, especially in summer.
-
Check what’s included: Some packages cover meals, entrance fees, or airport transfers. Knowing this ahead avoids surprises.
-
Pack for the weather: Even summer can bring rain and wind; layers, waterproof jackets, and sturdy shoes are essential. Read our guide on what to pack for Iceland for more details.
-
Be ready for the schedule: Guided tours have set times for each stop, so plan your rest and meal breaks around them.
-
Ask about flexibility: Some operators allow minor detours if you want a more unique experience.
Tips for Renting a Car in Iceland
-
Choose the right vehicle: A 4×4 is recommended for Highlands or winter travel, while a standard car works for summer Ring Road trips.
-
Plan your route: Decide which sights and regions to visit in advance, factoring in driving times and road conditions.
-
Check insurance options: Gravel protection, sand and ash coverage, and collision insurance are worth considering.
-
Watch the weather and road conditions: Icelandic conditions can change fast, so check road conditions and weather updates in Iceland daily.
-
Be mindful of fuel and services: Gas stations are sparse in remote areas, so plan refueling stops ahead.
-
Follow local driving rules: Keep headlights on at all times, drive cautiously on gravel roads, and respect speed limits to ensure safe driving in Iceland.
-
Check out: Best Advice For Renting a Car in Iceland
Making the Right Choice for Your Iceland Adventure
Choosing between guided tours and renting a car in Iceland comes down to your travel style and priorities. If you want stress-free planning and expert guidance, guided tours are ideal. If you crave flexibility and the freedom to explore at your own pace, a rental car in Iceland is the way to go.
If you’re staying for a more extended trip, vacation packages in Iceland offer a well-organized experience, with accommodations, transport, and activities all planned out. On the other hand, self-drive tours in Iceland still give you flexibility while following a detailed itinerary, so you can explore at your own pace without missing key sights.
Either way, the goal is the same: enjoying Iceland safely and making the most of every moment.
Thinking about renting a car or joining a guided tour in Iceland? Share your plans in the comments and tell us which option excites you the most. We’d love to hear how you’re planning to explore this amazing country!
