Rental Car Sizes in Iceland: What Type of Car to Rent (2024–2026 Study)

Last updated: Nov 19, 2026
Ingólfur Shahin
Verified expert
Last updated: Nov 19, 2026

Infographic summarizing a study of rental car sizes in Iceland, from 4x4 demand by season to the cost of a 4x4 upgrade.

Free to use with credit and a link, CC BY 4.0

We analyzed Guide to Iceland car rental bookings from 2024 to 2026. This study shows which rental car size is best, the pros and cons of each, and whether you need a 4x4. Find the perfect car for your itinerary and the time of your visit to Iceland.

Choosing the right rental car in Iceland is the key to experiencing the country’s landscapes. From the famous Ring Road, which stretches 821 miles (1,322 kilometers) around the country, to the Highlands, having the right vehicle gives you the freedom to explore Iceland at your own pace.

The best car size for self-drive tours in Iceland depends on your budget, group size, travel plan, and the time of your visit. Your choice of accommodation, whether it’s a hotel in Reykjavik or accommodation around Iceland, can also influence your decision.

Why You Can Trust Our Content

Guide to Iceland is the most trusted travel platform in Iceland, helping millions of visitors each year. All our content is written and reviewed by local experts who are deeply familiar with Iceland. You can count on us for accurate, up-to-date, and trustworthy travel advice.

With so many options available, choosing the right rental car can be tricky. To help you decide, we analyzed Guide to Iceland’s booking and review data, along with 5,856 Reddit comments, to see which car sizes travelers choose and how they rate their experiences.

This guide compares rental car sizes and matches each size to the best itineraries in Iceland. Whether you’re planning a short getaway or a longer adventure through the Icelandic Highlands, you’ll find practical advice to help you choose the right car for your trip.

Key Findings

  • Four-wheel-drive rental cars make up 84% of Guide to Iceland bookings picked up in February and 57% of those picked up in August.

  • In summer, travelers rate small budget rental cars in Iceland higher than 4x4s. Budget 2WD cars average 4.37 out of 5 stars, while standard 4x4s average 4.19.

  • The type of rental car in Iceland barely changes how satisfied travelers are. Budget cars, 4x4s, and premium SUVs all average between 4.26 and 4.36 stars.

  • The rental company affects car rental review scores in Iceland more than ten times as much as the car model.

  • An August rental day in Iceland costs 84% more than an April rental day, across all car types.

  • Upgrading from a budget 2WD car to a 4x4 in Iceland costs 5% more in April and 36% more in November.

  • Fewer than 1% of one- and two-star car rental reviews say the car could not handle the road.

  • Travelers who pick up a rental car in Reykjavik book a budget 2WD car 40% of the time, compared with 26% at Keflavik International Airport.

Cite This Study

The charts and data in this study are free to use under CC BY 4.0. Credit Guide to Iceland and link to this page. Every chart has an Embed button underneath it with ready-to-paste code.

At a Glance: What Car to Rent in Iceland by Month

When you travel What to rent Why
June to August, on the Ring Road or the Golden Circle A budget 2WD car, but not the smallest class Budget 2WD cars score highest in summer, and most summer routes do not need a 4x4.
June to August, with F-roads planned A standard 4x4, or a large 4x4 for unbridged river crossings Rental companies require 4x4s on F-roads, and unbridged rivers need high-clearance vehicles. Since river damage isn't insured, extra clearance reduces your risk.
April and May A standard SUV or 4x4 Snow and ice are still possible on mountain roads, and the 4x4 upgrade costs only 5% more in April and 25% more in May.
September and October A standard SUV or 4x4 The first fall storms and snow arrive, so the 4x4 is for road safety, not higher ratings. The upgrade costs 29% to 32% more.
November to March A standard SUV or 4x4 with winter tires Winter is the only season when the 4x4 scores slightly higher than the budget 2WD car.
Any month, if you plan to pay for a premium SUV Spend the money on a better-rated rental company instead The premium SUV never scores highest in any season.

The Best Type of Rental Car in Iceland Depends on the Season

A rental SUV drives a gravel road through black sand dunes toward Vestrahorn Mountain on the Stokksnes Peninsula at sunset.The best type of car to rent in Iceland depends on the season and the roads you plan to drive. A budget 2WD car suits most summer road trips, while a 4x4 suits most winter self-drive tours and highland adventures.

In this study, “budget 2WD” means mini, economy, compact, and mid-size cars with two-wheel drive. “Standard 4x4” means compact SUVs and small jeeps with four-wheel drive.

First-time drivers in Iceland can prepare with our guides to driving in Iceland and Icelandic road signs. Check that your driver’s license is valid in Iceland before you travel. Our guide to rental car and road information in Iceland explains how to find driving help on the road.

Best Rental Car in Iceland in Summer (June to August)

  • A budget two-wheel-drive car is enough for most trips to Iceland between June and August. These cars also receive the highest review scores from Guide to Iceland customers during this season.

  • Don’t choose a car based on price alone. A larger vehicle with more ground clearance can make driving on Iceland’s rough gravel roads more comfortable, even if you don’t need 4WD. Gravel roads are more common on the Snaefellsnes Peninsula and in the Westfjords than on the South Coast.

  • If your summer itinerary includes F-roads in the Icelandic Highlands, you’ll need a 4x4 vehicle. For unbridged river crossings, you need a large, high-clearance 4x4 car, not a compact SUV.

Best Rental Car for Iceland in Winter (November to March)

  • From November to March, book a 4x4 car rental in Iceland and check that it has winter tires. In February, 4x4 vehicles account for 84% of Guide to Iceland rental car pickups.

  • Winter is also the only season when 4x4 cars receive slightly higher customer ratings than budget cars, scoring 4.33 versus 4.31 out of 5. However, upgrading to a 4x4 costs the most in November, when prices are 36% higher than for a budget 2WD car.

Rental Car Sizes and Types Available in Iceland

Rental cars in Iceland fall into nine main classes, from 4- to 5-seat minicars to 9-seat passenger vans. Small 2WD cars suit paved summer roads, while 4x4 SUVs and jeeps suit gravel roads, winter driving, and F-roads.

Rental car class Typical seats Typical luggage Examples on Guide to Iceland Best for
Mini and subcompact 4 to 5 1 large + 1 small bag Toyota Aygo, Hyundai i10 Reykjavik and paved day trips
Economy and compact 5 1 large + 2 small bags Toyota Yaris Ring Road and Golden Circle in summer for two people
Mid-size and station wagon 5 2 large + 2 small bags Toyota Corolla, Kia Ceed Paved roads with more luggage
Compact SUV or crossover 5 2 large + 2 small bags Dacia Duster, Suzuki Vitara, Toyota RAV4 Gravel roads and winter, if the car is a 4x4
Small 4x4 jeep 2 2 small bags Suzuki Jimny Easier F-roads for two people who pack light
Large 4x4 and premium SUV 5 to 7 3 to 4 large bags Toyota Land Cruiser, Land Rover Defender F-roads and unbridged rivers (large 4x4)
Minivan 7 1 large + 2 small bags with all seats in use Dacia Jogger Families on paved roads
Passenger van 9 6 to 9 bags Toyota Proace, Renault Trafic Large groups with lots of luggage
Campervan 2 to 3 2 soft bags Dacia Dokker, VW Transporter Sleeping in the vehicle on paved roads

“SUV” describes a body shape, not a drivetrain, so an SUV rental car in Iceland is not always a 4x4. The Dacia Duster and the Nissan Qashqai both come in 2WD and 4x4 models on Guide to Iceland.

Nearly every Dacia Duster booked through Guide to Iceland is a 4x4, but only a third of Nissan Qashqai bookings are 4x4s. If you book for winter or a gravel route, check the drivetrain of the specific vehicle, not the class name.

Pros and Cons of Each Rental Car Size in Iceland

Rental cars in Iceland differ in price, luggage space, and road suitability. The table below compares each size to help you choose based on your group and route.

Car size Pros Cons
Small and economy cars Lowest daily price, lowest fuel use, and easy parking in Reykjavik Little luggage space, low ground clearance, and not allowed on F-roads
Mid-size cars and station wagons More luggage space at a budget price Low clearance on rough gravel roads
Compact SUVs and 4x4s Higher clearance, better grip in winter, and access to easier F-roads Higher price and fuel use than a budget car
Large 4x4s and premium SUVs The only rental cars suited to F3 roads and river crossings About twice the price of a standard 4x4
Minivans and passenger vans One vehicle and one driver for a whole group Harder to drive in strong wind and on narrow roads
Campervans Car and accommodation in one booking Most are not allowed on F-roads, and many are mainly booked in summer

The Right Rental Car Size in Iceland for Your Group or Family

The right rental car size in Iceland depends on how many people travel and how much luggage you bring.

  • Solo travelers and couples: An economy car suits a summer trip on the Ring Road. A compact 4x4 suits a winter trip or gravel roads.

  • Three or four travelers: A station wagon or a compact SUV fits four people and their luggage. Choose the 4x4 version for winter.

  • Five travelers: A seven-seat minivan with the third row folded down fits five people and their luggage. A large 4x4 fits five people, but only three to four large suitcases.

  • Six to nine travelers: A nine-seat passenger van carries the whole group and its luggage in one vehicle.

  • Families: A station wagon or a compact SUV fits two adults, two children, and their luggage. A family of five or more travels more comfortably in a seven-seat minivan, such as the Dacia Jogger.

If you are new to driving in Iceland, choose a car size similar to the one you drive at home. A familiar car is easier to handle on narrow roads, gravel roads, and one-lane bridges.

You Don’t Always Need a 4x4 in Iceland

Line chart of the monthly share of rental car pickups in Iceland by car type, with 4x4 rentals peaking in February.

Free to use with credit and a link, CC BY 4.0

A budget 2WD car is enough for most summer trips in Iceland from June to August, including the Ring Road and the Golden Circle. Outside summer, and on designated F-roads, choose a 4x4.

Our rental data shows that demand for 4x4 vehicles is highest in winter and drops during the summer months.

In a 2017 Vegagerdin survey of around 1,600 foreign rental car drivers, about 86% had driven on gravel roads, but only 40% had rented a 4x4. This suggests many visitors drive on gravel roads in standard cars, particularly in summer.

4x4 Rentals in Iceland Peak in February and Drop in Summer

Standard SUVs and 4x4s are the most-booked rental cars in Iceland in every month of the year. Their share of monthly pickups peaks at 79% in February, then falls every month to its low of 52% in August. This means travelers book a 4x4 car more often in winter than in summer.

Budget 2WD cars in Iceland follow the opposite trend, increasing from 13% of pickups in February to 32% in August. Premium SUVs account for a smaller but steady share of 3% to 6% throughout the year, reaching their highest point in November.

Together, standard 4x4s and premium SUVs in Iceland make up 84% of February pickups and 57% of August pickups. Highland roads open in June and July, but premium SUV bookings peak in November.

Note: Campervans, motorhomes, and nine-seat vans are counted in the total but not plotted. Their share is smallest in winter, at about 3% in February, and largest in summer, at about 11% in August.

Mid-Size Car Rental in Iceland Is Enough for Most Summer Trips

A mid-size rental car is enough for most summer trips on the Ring Road, the Golden Circle, and the South Coast. Mid-size cars and station wagons, such as the Toyota Corolla and Kia Ceed, seat five people and typically fit two large and two small bags.

Mid-size cars belong to the budget 2WD group, which scores 4.37 out of 5 in summer, the highest of any car type. From November to March, or if you plan to drive F-roads, choose a 4x4 instead.

Read our guides to driving in Iceland in June, driving in Iceland in July, and driving in Iceland in August to plan your summer road trip.

A 4x4 Is Recommended for Driving in Iceland in Winter

Two Toyota Land Cruiser 4x4 rental cars parked on snow in Iceland in winter.A 4x4 rental car is recommended for driving in Iceland in winter, but it does not guarantee safe travel on icy roads. Winter tires, ground clearance, and careful driving are just as important. SafeTravel explains that a 4x4 can help but cannot prevent skidding on ice.

The main advantages of a 4x4 in December, January, and February are better traction when accelerating on snow and more ground clearance on slushy roads and unplowed parking areas. These features can make a larger 4x4 SUV more practical than a small 2WD car for some winter itineraries.

For more planning advice, our weather study of the best and worst months to visit Iceland compares the weather in each month. Winter self-drive tours in Iceland combine a rental car with a planned route.

Winter Tires Matter More Than a 4x4 on Iceland’s Icy Roads

If you’re comparing rental car sizes in Iceland for a winter trip, prioritize suitable winter tires before paying extra for a larger vehicle or four-wheel drive.

Winter tires provide traction on snow and ice, while four-wheel drive improves power distribution to the wheels. This means a 4x4 with winter tires can help you get moving on slippery roads.

Iceland requires a minimum tire tread depth of 0.12 inches (3 millimeters) from November 1 to April 14 under Regulation 736/2014. Winter tires are essential during this period, even though the law does not explicitly require them.

Studded tires are allowed in Iceland from November 1 to April 14. According to the Icelandic Police, their use is generally prohibited from April 15 to October 31 unless severe winter conditions justify an exception.

Winter Road Closures in Iceland Affect Every Rental Car, Even a 4x4

Even the largest 4x4 rental car cannot make an unsafe or closed road passable.

The Icelandic Road and Coastal Administration provides winter maintenance for about 3,100 miles (5,000 kilometers) of Iceland’s 7,500 miles (12,000 kilometers) of classified roads. Some roads are cleared only twice a week, while others may close during severe weather.

Before choosing your rental car and planning your route, consider which roads you intend to drive. Check weather warnings in Iceland and road conditions every morning, and be prepared to change your plans when necessary.

Read our guides to driving in Iceland in December, driving in Iceland in January, and driving in Iceland in February to plan your winter road trip.

Budget Rental Cars Get Slightly Better Reviews Than 4x4s in Iceland

Chart of review scores for budget cars, 4x4s, and premium SUVs rented in Iceland in summer, spring and fall, and winter.

Free to use with credit and a link, CC BY 4.0

Budget 2WD cars have the highest satisfaction rate in Iceland, especially in summer. Across all Guide to Iceland car reviews, budget 2WD cars average 4.36 out of 5 stars, premium SUVs 4.35, and standard SUVs and 4x4s 4.26.

The type of car changes traveler satisfaction only slightly. All three car tiers score within 0.10 stars of each other.

Vehicle tier Average review score Five-star reviews One- or two-star reviews
Budget 2WD 4.36 69% 11%
Premium SUV 4.35 70% 12%
Standard SUV / 4x4 4.26 66% 13%

Overall, the rental company you choose has a greater influence on customer satisfaction than the type of car you rent. Season, however, makes a difference when comparing vehicle types.

Budget Rental Cars Score Highest in Iceland in Summer

In summer, budget 2WD cars score 4.37 and standard 4x4s score 4.19. The scores compare cars rented from the same companies, so a good or bad rental company does not affect the result.

During winter, standard 4x4s score 4.33 and budget 2WD cars score 4.31. This makes winter the only season when the 4x4 catches up with the budget car. The winter budget car score is based on only 141 reviews, because few travelers rent a small car in winter.

In spring and fall, budget 2WD cars still lead, at 4.40 against 4.29 for standard 4x4s.

Review scores measure how satisfied travelers are with the rental, not how the car handles snow or ice. We still recommend a 4x4 in spring and fall because Iceland’s weather can change quickly in these months.

Premium SUVs Never Have the Highest Score in Any Season

Premium SUVs do not lead in any season, despite bookings peaking in November. Larger 4x4s are useful on F-roads, but these routes generally close from mid-September until June or July, depending on conditions.

Car Type Changes Traveler Ratings in Iceland Less Than the Rental Company

A green Dacia Duster rental SUV on a paved road leading toward volcanic mountains on the Reykjanes Peninsula.The type of rental car you choose barely changes how you rate your trip in Iceland. Average review scores for budget cars, 4x4s, and premium SUVs differ by only 0.10 stars.

Compare rental companies before you compare car models. Our ranking of car rental companies in Iceland names the best-rated company and compares all 37 companies on 49,273 reviews.

No Single Rental Car or SUV Is the Best for Iceland

Chart comparing raw and adjusted review scores for 29 rental car models in Iceland, including the Dacia Duster.

Free to use with credit and a link, CC BY 4.0

No single rental car model is clearly better than the others in Iceland. Once you compare cars rented from the same company, the gaps between popular models almost disappear.

On raw review scores, the Toyota Land Cruiser leads with an average of 4.73 out of 5, followed by the Toyota RAV4 at 4.57. The Suzuki Vitara and Suzuki Jimny score lower, at 4.01 and 3.99, respectively.

Raw scores mix the car with the rental company that rents it. A model rented mostly by highly rated companies gets a higher raw score, even if the car itself is no better.

The chart shows each model twice. The hollow circle is the raw score, and the filled circle is the score after the rental company is taken into account. A long line between the two circles means the rental company was driving that model’s raw score.

Popular Rental Car Models in Iceland Score Almost the Same From the Same Company

Popular 4x4 rental cars in Iceland score almost the same when you compare cars rented from the same company. The Suzuki Vitara, Suzuki Jimny, Toyota RAV4, Toyota Land Cruiser, and Land Rover Defender all land within about 0.20 stars of the Dacia Duster. None of these differences are statistically significant.

To compare the cars fairly, Guide to Iceland compared models rented from the same rental companies. The Dacia Duster, the most-rented car on Guide to Iceland, is the benchmark.

The Toyota RAV4’s higher raw score and the Suzuki Vitara’s lower raw score come mostly from the rental companies that rent them, not from the cars.

The Car Model Barely Changes Rental Car Reviews in Iceland

The rental company alone explains 11.3% of the differences in Guide to Iceland car rental review scores. Adding the car model explains only 0.75 percentage points more. This shows that choosing a well-rated rental company matters more than choosing a specific car model in Iceland.

Some models in the chart have fewer than 30 reviews, such as the Hyundai i30 and the Suzuki S-Cross. Scores for these models can swing widely, so treat them as less reliable than models with hundreds of reviews.

Most F-Roads in Iceland Need a 4x4 Rental Car

A large 4x4 jeep crosses an unbridged river on the F-road to Askja Caldera in the Icelandic Highlands.In Iceland, F-roads are the one case where the type of car decides whether you can make the trip. F-roads need a 4x4, and roads with unbridged rivers need a large, high-clearance 4x4.

Vegagerdin, the Icelandic Road and Coastal Administration, divides mountain roads into three classes. The car examples come from SafeTravel and match the rental car classes in this study:

  • F1 roads: Passable for general traffic in summer.

  • F2 roads: Passable for four-wheel-drive vehicles, powerful passenger cars, and jeeps.

  • F3 roads: Include difficult terrain and river crossings. Accessible only for large, well-equipped 4x4s and Super Jeeps.

Some F-roads are fine for a Dacia Duster, others need a Toyota Land Cruiser or larger, and some need a modified Super Jeep. SafeTravel also warns that not every 4x4 is suitable for F-roads.

Rental companies in Iceland generally do not allow 2WD cars on any F-road, including F1 roads. Check your rental agreement before you plan a highland route.

Iceland’s Highland Roads Open in June or July and Close in Mid-September

Highland roads in Iceland are closed for most of the year and usually open only in summer. A 4x4 rental car is required to drive these routes. The table shows average opening dates from Vegagerdin opening data for 2021 to 2025.

Highland road Section Average opening date
Kjalvegur (Route 35) Gullfoss Waterfall to Hveravellir Geothermal Area June 1
F208 Sigalda to Landmannalaugar Nature Reserve June 2
F208 Landmannalaugar to Eldgja Canyon June 25
Sprengisandur (F26) Hrauneyjar to Nyidalur July 6

SafeTravel states that highland roads usually close again in mid-September. A large 4x4 does not give you highland access in January.

If the highlands are your main goal, plan your trip for Iceland in July or August and read our guide to the Icelandic Highlands. Our list of the top places to visit in the Highlands of Iceland helps you choose where to drive with a 4x4.

No Rental Car Insurance in Iceland Covers River Crossings

No rental car insurance in Iceland covers damage from crossing a river, according to SafeTravel.

If your route crosses an unbridged river, choose a large 4x4, such as a Toyota Land Cruiser. The road into Thorsmork Valley crosses some of Iceland’s most dangerous rivers. The safest way to visit Thorsmork Valley is with highland tours, 4x4 off-road tours, or Super Jeep tours.

Upgrading to a 4x4 in Iceland Costs 5% to 36% More Than a Budget Car

April is the cheapest month to upgrade to a 4x4 in Iceland
How much more a standard 4x4 costs per day than a budget 2WD car, by pickup month. Based on the median price actually paid per rental day.
January
 
+16%
February
 
+16%
March
 
+13%
April
 
+5%
May
 
+25%
June
 
+20%
July
 
+19%
August
 
+22%
September
 
+29%
October
 
+32%
November
 
+36%
December
 
+19%
Source: Guide to Iceland analysis of standalone car rental bookings, pickups January 1, 2024, to September 12, 2026.
Free to use with credit and a link, CC BY 4.0

Upgrading from a budget 2WD car to a 4x4 in Iceland costs between 5% and 36% more per day, depending on the month. April is the cheapest month to upgrade, and November is the most expensive. In summer, a 4x4 costs about 20% more than a budget car.

A 4x4 upgrade in Iceland costs the most from September to November, at 29% to 36% more than a budget car. Budget car prices fall sharply after summer, while 4x4 prices stay higher. November has both the cheapest budget car day of the year and the largest 4x4 upgrade cost.

Vehicle tier Cheapest month Most expensive month
Premium SUV May, about 20,600 ISK July, 34,806 ISK
Standard SUV / 4x4 April, about 9,300 ISK August, 17,864 ISK
Budget 2WD November, 8,200 ISK July and August, about 14,700 to 14,800 ISK

A Premium SUV Costs About Twice as Much as a Standard 4x4 in Iceland

Line chart of the median rental car price per day in Iceland by month for budget cars, 4x4s, and premium SUVs.

Free to use with credit and a link, CC BY 4.0

Across the year, the median price per rental day in Iceland is 10,837 ISK for a budget 2WD car, 13,091 ISK for a standard 4x4, and 25,073 ISK for a premium SUV. All prices in this study are in Icelandic krona (ISK).

A premium SUV in Iceland costs about twice as much per day as a standard 4x4. The premium SUV is a separate price class, not a small upgrade.

Travel Dates Change Rental Car Prices in Iceland More Than the Type

Rental car prices in Iceland peak in July and August for every vehicle tier. Across all car types, an August rental day costs 84% more than an April rental day. If your dates are flexible, traveling in a cheaper month saves more money than choosing a smaller car.

Our study of the cheapest time to visit Iceland shows how travel prices change through the year. Our guides to car rental costs in Iceland and how expensive Iceland is compare the car with your other travel costs.

Travelers Rarely Complain About Their Rental Car Type in Iceland

Almost no one complains about the type of car they booked
Share of each vehicle tier’s one- and two-star reviews that mention each theme. A review can mention more than one theme.
■Budget 2WD (116 reviews)■Standard SUV / 4x4 (373 reviews)
Condition of the car
 
25.9%
 
31.6%
The pickup desk and the wait
 
11.2%
 
11.0%
Insurance upsell or deposit hold
 
7.8%
 
7.0%
A different car than the one booked
 
1.7%
 
2.4%
Damage charged on return
 
1.7%
 
0.8%
The car was too small
 
0.0%
 
0.8%
The car could not handle the road
 
0.9%
 
0.5%
Source: Guide to Iceland analysis of 4,157 verified car rental reviews matched to the exact car booked, pickups 2018 to 2026. Premium SUVs have only 27 low-star reviews and are left out.
Free to use with credit and a link, CC BY 4.0

Travelers in Iceland rarely complain about the type of rental car they booked. Fewer than 1% of one- and two-star Guide to Iceland car rental reviews say the car could not handle the road.

Only 0.9% of low-star reviews for budget 2WD cars say the car could not handle the road. For standard 4x4s, the figure is 0.5%. No low-star reviews for budget 2WD cars say the car was too small, compared with 0.8% for standard 4x4s.

Choosing between a 2WD and a 4x4 is a common question when you plan an Iceland road trip. However, the choice rarely appears as a complaint after the trip.

The top complaints for both car types are about the car’s condition and the rental service, not the car type. These complaints depend on the rental company you choose. Read our tips for renting a car in Iceland to learn what to check at pickup.

The Dacia Duster Is the Most-Discussed Rental Car on Reddit

The Dacia Duster is the most-named rental car on Reddit
Reddit comments that name each car. The Duster gets more mentions than the RAV4, Land Cruiser, and Vitara combined.
Dacia Duster
 
154
Suzuki Jimny
 
81
Toyota Land Cruiser
 
63
Toyota RAV4
 
50
Toyota Yaris
 
39
Land Rover Defender
 
23
Kia Sportage
 
21
Hyundai i10
 
15
Suzuki Vitara
 
13
Subaru Forester or Outback
 
8
Toyota Aygo
 
8
Source: Guide to Iceland analysis of 5,856 comments in 237 threads in r/VisitingIceland and r/Iceland, collected in September 2026.
Free to use with credit and a link, CC BY 4.0

The Dacia Duster is the most-discussed rental car in Iceland on Reddit, with 154 comments. The Toyota RAV4, Toyota Land Cruiser, and Suzuki Vitara receive 126 comments combined. Guide to Iceland analyzed 5,856 comments across 237 threads in r/VisitingIceland and r/Iceland.

The Suzuki Jimny is the second most-discussed rental car on Reddit, with 81 comments. The Toyota Yaris is the most-discussed small 2WD car, with 39 comments.

Reddit comments that name a Toyota Land Cruiser, Land Rover Defender, or Super Jeep mention F-roads more often than summer or winter. Travelers link the largest 4x4s with highland driving, not with the season.

Reddit travelers mention four-wheel drive with winter about 2.5 times more often than with summer. This matches Guide to Iceland booking data, which shows the highest demand for 4x4 rental cars in winter.

When choosing a rental car in Iceland, Reddit travelers most often discuss wind and sandstorms (318 comments), gravel roads and windshield damage (297), and F-roads and the Highlands (170). Car rental insurance gets more comments than all three combined. Our ranking of the best car rental companies in Iceland covers what travelers say about insurance and deposits.

Travelers From 31 of 33 Countries Book Mostly 4x4 Rental Cars in Iceland

Italians book the most 4x4s, Canadians the most small cars
Vehicle tier by the traveler’s home market, as a share of each market’s rentals. In brackets: that market’s share of all Guide to Iceland car rentals.
■Budget 2WD■Standard SUV / 4x4■Premium SUV■Camper, motorhome, or van
Thailand (<2%)
11
22
14
52
Italy (3%)
12
77
 
8
France (6%)
14
69
 
14
Taiwan (3%)
17
62
11
10
Spain (2%)
18
72
 
9
Portugal (<2%)
18
68
 
10
Poland (2%)
18
66
 
12
Austria (<2%)
19
68
 
12
Netherlands (<2%)
19
70
 
6
Malaysia (<2%)
19
58
9
13
Hong Kong (2%)
19
70
8
 
Switzerland (2%)
20
67
 
9
Czechia (<2%)
22
60
 
15
Germany (6%)
22
65
 
9
Belgium (<2%)
22
69
 
5
United Kingdom (4%)
23
70
 
 
India (<2%)
23
65
 
8
Mexico (<2%)
24
67
 
7
South Korea (3%)
24
58
 
14
Ireland (<2%)
26
68
 
 
Singapore (<2%)
27
64
6
 
Denmark (2%)
27
58
6
9
Norway (<2%)
27
63
 
7
Iceland (4%)
28
61
5
7
China (5%)
30
54
10
6
Russia (<2%)
30
39
10
21
Sweden (<2%)
32
55
 
9
United States (30%)
32
57
5
5
Australia (<2%)
32
60
 
 
Ukraine (<2%)
34
56
 
8
Japan (7%)
36
56
 
6
Finland (<2%)
37
52
 
9
Canada (4%)
38
51
 
7
Source: Guide to Iceland analysis of standalone car rental bookings, pickups January 1, 2024, to September 12, 2026. Markets with at least 50 standalone car rentals. Shares under 5% are unlabeled. Markets travel in different seasons, so part of each gap reflects when travelers visit.
Free to use with credit and a link, CC BY 4.0

Rental car choice in Iceland varies sharply by the traveler’s home country. Italian travelers put 77% of their bookings into a standard 4x4 and only 12% into a budget car. Canadian travelers book the highest share of budget cars of any market, at 38%.

Travelers from Thailand book premium SUVs more often than any other market, accounting for 14% of their rentals. Taiwan (11%), China (10%), and Russia (10%) follow. Thai travelers also have the highest share of campervan and van bookings, at 52%.

A standard 4x4 makes up more than half of rentals in 31 of the 33 markets. Russia and Thailand are the only exceptions. Even Canadian travelers, the most budget-minded market, book a 4x4 (51%) more often than a budget car (38%).

Travelers from the United States make up 30% of all Guide to Iceland car rentals, the largest single market. American travelers book a standard 4x4 for 57% of rentals and a budget 2WD for 32%.

The table below compares rental car choices for travelers from 33 countries, each with at least 50 standalone car bookings.

Home market Budget 2WD Standard 4x4 Premium SUV Camper or van Winter pickups
United States 32% 57% 5% 5% 20%
Japan 36% 56% 2% 6% 34%
France 14% 69% 3% 14% 31%
Germany 22% 65% 4% 9% 22%
China 30% 54% 10% 6% 25%
Canada 38% 51% 4% 7% 12%
Iceland 28% 61% 5% 7% 30%
United Kingdom 23% 70% 4% 3% 54%
South Korea 24% 58% 4% 14% 41%
Italy 12% 77% 3% 8% 31%
Taiwan 17% 62% 11% 10% 32%
Hong Kong 19% 70% 8% 3% 35%
Switzerland 20% 67% 4% 9% 23%
Denmark 27% 58% 6% 9% 22%
Poland 18% 66% 4% 12% 34%
Spain 18% 72% 2% 9% 27%
Netherlands 19% 70% 4% 6% 28%
Australia 32% 60% 4% 3% 25%
Sweden 32% 55% 4% 9% 12%
Norway 27% 63% 3% 7% 18%
Austria 19% 68% 2% 12% 20%
Czechia 22% 60% 2% 15% 10%
Belgium 22% 69% 3% 5% 20%
Singapore 27% 64% 6% 4% 33%
Finland 37% 52% 3% 9% 13%
India 23% 65% 3% 8% 23%
Mexico 24% 67% 2% 7% 35%
Ukraine 34% 56% 2% 8% 18%
Russia 30% 39% 10% 21% 9%
Thailand 11% 22% 14% 52% 40%
Ireland 26% 68% 2% 4% 56%
Malaysia 19% 58% 9% 13% 28%
Portugal 18% 68% 4% 10% 34%

Markets are listed from largest to smallest share of bookings. “Iceland” refers to Icelandic residents renting through Guide to Iceland. Percentages may not add up to exactly 100% because of rounding.

Travel Season Explains Why Rental Car Choices in Iceland Differ by Country

The travel season affects car choice, because markets visit Iceland at different times of the year. Canadian travelers make only 12% of their pickups in winter, which partly explains their high share of budget cars. Travelers from the United Kingdom and Ireland make more than half of their pickups in winter.

Looking only at winter bookings, travelers from Denmark and Iceland choose a small 2WD car for 24% of rentals. Japan and Canada follow at 23%, and the United States at 22%. By comparison, small 2WD cars make up just 5% of winter rentals for Italian travelers and 9% for French travelers.

Winter driving experience at home may play a role, but it does not explain every difference. Travelers from Norway, Austria, and Switzerland still favor 4x4s in winter despite snowy roads at home.

Travelers Who Pick Up in Reykjavik Book Budget Cars More Often

About 93% of standalone car rentals through Guide to Iceland are picked up at Keflavik International Airport. Another 7% are picked up in Reykjavik, and less than 1% are picked up anywhere else in Iceland.

Pickup location also affects the type of car travelers choose. At Reykjavik rental locations, 40% of customers book a budget 2WD car, compared with 26% at Keflavik Airport. A Reykjavik pickup may mean a shorter, city-based trip with fewer rough roads.

Travelers who land at Keflavik Airport and drive straight out on a road trip book larger cars more often. Compare car rentals at Keflavik Airport or car rentals in Reykjavik to match the car to your route. Airport pickup differs by company, and rental car pickup at Keflavik Airport can mean a terminal desk, a short walk, or a free shuttle.

Campervans, Vans, and Roof Tent Cars Make Up Under 9% of Iceland Rentals

Campervans, motorhomes, passenger vans, and roof tent cars make up a small share of rental bookings on Guide to Iceland. Of all standalone car rentals, 4.8% are campers or motorhomes, 2.8% are vans or minivans, and 0.9% are cars with roof tents.

A campervan or mini camper rental in Iceland combines your car and your accommodation in one booking. About 65% of camper pickups on Guide to Iceland happen in June, July, or August. Most campervans are not permitted on F-roads, which means travelers generally need a different vehicle to access the Highlands.

Motorhome and RV rentals in Iceland are the larger version of a campervan. A motorhome gives you more space, but it is harder to drive and park on narrow roads.

A seven-seat Dacia Jogger or a nine-seat Toyota Proace lets a group travel in one vehicle. A van needs only one driver, but it uses more fuel and is harder to drive on narrow roads. Plan your fuel stops with our guide to gas stations in Iceland.

A roof tent car is a Dacia Duster, Suzuki Vitara, or Mitsubishi Outlander with a tent on top. A roof tent car drives like a 4x4, so it is one of the few ways to combine highland access with sleeping in your vehicle.

How We Analyzed Iceland’s Rental Car Bookings and Reviews

This study covers Guide to Iceland car rentals picked up between January 1, 2024, and September 12, 2026. Cars in a package or self-drive tour are left out because the traveler does not choose the car.

Prices are the median price actually paid per rental day, not advertised rates. Seasons are defined as summer (June to August), shoulder (April, May, September, and October), and winter (November to March).

How Vehicles Were Grouped Into Tiers

Each vehicle was sorted into budget 2WD, standard SUV / 4x4, premium SUV, camper, or van by make, model, drive type, and seats. Two-wheel-drive versions of SUVs and crossovers count as budget 2WD. Median prices rise with each tier, which supports the sorting.

Review Data

Car reviews on Guide to Iceland rate the rental company, not the car. Guide to Iceland matched each review to its booking to find the exact vehicle. This gives 4,157 verified reviews across three tiers and 64 companies, for pickups from 2018 to 2026.

How Cars Were Compared Fairly

Rental companies differ a lot in how customers rate them. To remove this effect, every vehicle comparison uses cars rented from the same company. Scores come from a regression on vehicle tier, season, pickup year, and rental company, with standard errors clustered by company.

The summer gap between budget 2WD cars and standard 4x4s is 0.185 stars (p = 0.005). The model comparison uses 3,800 reviews of 29 models with at least 15 reviews each. Raw averages appear next to the adjusted scores so you can see the difference.

Complaint Analysis

The complaint analysis uses 489 one- and two-star reviews out of 3,936 for the two main tiers. Themes are coded by keyword, and a review can have several themes. The premium SUV tier has only 27 low-star reviews, so the complaint chart leaves it out.

Reddit and Travel Forum Data

Traveler sentiment comes from 5,856 Reddit comments in 237 threads, collected in September 2026 and grouped by keyword. The study also reviewed car-choice threads on the TripAdvisor Iceland forum and the Rick Steves Iceland travel forum.

Conclusion: Which Rental Car Size to Book in Iceland

A small 2WD rental car drives a gravel road past an 80 km/h speed limit sign in Iceland.The season you travel decides whether you need a 4x4 in Iceland. A budget 2WD car suits most summer trips, and a 4x4 with winter tires suits most winter trips.

F-roads are the main exception. Rental companies require a 4x4 on F-roads, and unbridged rivers need a large 4x4. The rental company affects review scores more than ten times as much as the car model. Compare rental companies before you compare cars.

Guide to Iceland works with car rental partners across Iceland and applies the same safety standards and service requirements to every partner. Compare every vehicle and every partner on the Iceland car rentals page to book the right car for your trip.

What Our Other Studies Say About Choosing a Rental Car in Iceland

The right rental car size in Iceland depends mainly on the season you travel. Our weather study of the best and worst months to visit Iceland compares 26 years of weather data by month. Use it to decide whether your trip needs a small 2WD car or a 4x4.

A small car costs the least in Iceland, and a larger car costs more in every month. Our study of the cheapest time to visit Iceland shows how travel prices change through the year. Traveling in a cheaper month can make a larger car more affordable.

The length of your trip affects how much you drive and how much luggage you carry. Our study of how many days you need in Iceland helps you plan the length of your road trip before you choose a car size.

A large 4x4 is the only car size for some F-roads, but you don’t have to drive them yourself. Our studies of the tours in Iceland with the highest satisfaction rate and tour cancellations in Iceland help you choose a guided highland tour instead.

Pick the Right Car Size. Our Studies Cover the Rest.Which car size fits your season, when prices fall, and how long to stay, from Guide to Iceland’s traveler studies→

Choosing a rental car size is one chapter in Guide to Iceland’s traveler studies. The series also covers Iceland’s best hidden gems, how often volcanoes erupt in Iceland, and glacier melting rates in Iceland.

About this study: Results use Guide to Iceland bookings from 2024 to 2026, 4,157 verified reviews matched to the exact car, 4,157 verified reviews from 2018 to 2026, and 5,856 Reddit comments. Guide to Iceland earns commissions, which play no part in the results. Booking counts are not published.

Ingólfur Shahin
Ingólfur Shahin
Verified expert
About the author

I was born on the west side of Reykjavík and grew up downtown, so Iceland has been my back yard for most of my life. I'm a father of two, I've traveled on five continents, and I still haven't found a country that holds my attention the way this one does.

That's why I co-founded Guide to Iceland. We connect travelers directly with Icelandic operators, guides and hosts, so the advice and the services both come from people who actually live here.

I write about the practical side of a trip: what eating out in Reykjavík really costs, whether to pick Sky Lagoon or Hvammsvík, where to stop for food along the Ring Road, and which regions give you the best odds of clear skies for the northern lights. If you're planning a trip and something doesn't add up, message me.

More by author
Link to appstore phone
Install Iceland’s biggest travel app

Download Iceland’s biggest travel marketplace to your phone to manage your entire trip in one place

Scan this QR code with your phone camera and press the link that appears to add Iceland’s biggest travel marketplace into your pocket. Enter your phone number or email address to receive an SMS or email with the download link.